DETAILED COMPARISON
Jotter Otter vs MagicPost
Two AI content tools. One delivers better results. Let's compare.
Best Value
Jotter Otter
AI-Powered Content Generation
PricingFrom $19.99/mo
Content QualityUnique, optimized
Platform Optimization
Hashtag Suggestions
Content Library
Templates
MagicPost
AI Content Creation Tool
PricingFrom $29/mo
Content QualityTemplate-based
Platform Optimization
Hashtag Suggestions
Content Library
Templates
Pricing Comparison
Jotter Otter
- Scout Plan: $19.99/month - 25 posts
- Hunter Plan: $49.99/month - Unlimited posts
- 7-day free trial
- Cancel anytime, no commitments
MagicPost
- Starter: $29/month - Limited features
- Pro: $59/month - More features
- Limited free trial
- Annual billing for best rates
Features
| Features | Jotter Otter | MagicPost |
|---|---|---|
| Generate unlimited posts | ||
| Generate post ideas | ||
| Generate hooks | ||
| Add and use your own writing style (or someone else's) | ||
| Duplicate and reuse a post (recycling) | ||
| Edit your post directly from the tool | ||
| Schedule your publications or select "publish now" | ||
| Find inspiration by filtering all posts already published on LinkedIn | ||
| Bookmark your favorite LinkedIn posts, ideas and hooks | ||
| Centralized and organized your generated posts | ||
| Access to dozens of LinkedIn post templates | ||
| Image analysis & topic extraction | ||
| Ask AI with specific instructions |
Summary
Jotter Otter: 11/13 features • MagicPost: 8/13 features
Pros & Cons
Jotter Otter
Pros
- 30% cheaper ($19.99 vs $29)
- Faster content generation
- Platform-optimized content automatically
- No templates - unique content every time
- Cleaner, more intuitive interface
- Better content quality and customization
Cons
- No hashtag suggestions
- No content library
- No LinkedIn post filtering or bookmarking
MagicPost
Pros
- Hashtag suggestion tools
- Content library for saving posts
- Basic scheduling features
- Template library for quick starts
Cons
- More expensive ($29+ vs $19.99)
- Template-based (less unique content)
- Slower generation times
- Less platform optimization
- Interface can feel cluttered
- Content can feel generic
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Jotter Otter if:
- You want unique, high-quality content (not templates)
- You need platform-optimized content automatically
- You want to save money ($9+/month)
- You prefer faster generation times
- You already have a scheduling tool or post manually
Choose MagicPost if:
- You need hashtag suggestion tools
- You want a content library to save posts
- You need basic scheduling features built-in
- You prefer template-based content creation
- Budget is less of a concern
Ready to Try Jotter Otter?
Get better content quality for less money. Start your 7-day free trial today.
Start Free Trial